Comic Book Grading
Comic Book Grading
Nines Finds uses traditional Overstreet comic book grading conventions to assess the condition of raw (uncertified) comic books.
We assign descriptive letter grades ranging from Near Mint (NM) through Poor (PR), using plus (+) and minus (−) modifiers where appropriate to distinguish condition within a grade.
Grades reflect our assessment of the comic’s overall physical condition, including cover wear, spine condition, page quality, structural integrity, completeness, and the cumulative effects of individual defects.
Nines Finds does not assign numerical grades to raw comics. Our condition assessments are independent dealer opinions and should not be interpreted as predictions or guarantees of grades assigned by CGC, CBCS, or another third-party grading service.
For professionally graded comics, we report the grade and certification information provided by the identified grading service.
We make reasonable efforts to identify and disclose significant defects using our published defect terminology. Buyers should review listing photographs and descriptions, particularly when condition is an important factor in their purchasing decisions.
Defect Disclosure
Condition descriptions use the Nines Finds Comic Defect Terminology glossary. Defects may be identified by type, severity, location, and size when practical.
Our severity terms are Slight, Minor, Moderate, Major, and Severe.
A defect’s presence does not automatically determine the grade. Its extent, location, effect on appearance or structure, and relationship to other defects are considered together.
Missing pages, significant missing pieces, detached components, repairs, and other material condition issues will be disclosed when identified.
Unless expressly stated otherwise, raw comic grades are Nines Finds dealer assessments and are not independently certified.